← Back to the blog

Common Sense Media Rates ChatGPT for Teens an Unacceptable Risk: What Parents Should Do

By Equipo IA University Kids · Published · Updated

Leer este artículo en español

Minimum age: 13

This tool requires adult supervision.

What's new

On October 7, 2026, Common Sense Media's Youth AI Safety Institute independently rated ChatGPT for Teens an Unacceptable Risk. It asked OpenAI to restrict ChatGPT to users 18 and older until the safety and learning protections the company promised parents actually work.

The Institute tested the product before and after OpenAI's August 18 teen-experience announcement. Analysts ran more than 4,000 prompts on accounts registered to 13- to 17-year-olds and had responses reviewed by child psychiatrists and a pediatrician. Some protections worked — including refusal of sexual roleplay. Others did not deliver on OpenAI's commitments.

Key findings from the assessment:

  1. Parent alerts that don't fire. On newly created, parent-linked accounts, testers spent up to an hour discussing suicidal ideation, self-harm, or disordered eating and got zero alerts. Notifications only appeared on much older accounts with weeks of sensitive conversation history.
  2. Unreliable crisis help. ChatGPT failed to reliably recommend a hotline or professional. It missed more than one in four warranted crisis referrals and fell below the Institute's 95% threshold on three of five Red Lines for severe harms.
  3. Study mode is easy to bypass. A "Show me the answer" pop-up often appeared inside study mode; caregiver-set study hours could be toggled off by deleting the @study prefix at the start of a prompt.
  4. It still talks like a friend. Despite an Under-18 model spec meant to curb friend-like behavior, the bot still expressed feelings, preferences, and moods.
  5. Age estimation didn't work. Adult-registered test accounts never switched to the under-18 experience — even when testers said they were 13 and the bot acknowledged it.

Tom Siegel, executive director of the Institute, put it plainly: "A teen can spend an hour talking about self-harm without their parent getting a single alert." Marketplace covered the report on November 5, 2026.

Why it matters for parents and teachers

This isn't OpenAI's feature launch — it's an independent audit of whether those features work in practice. The family risk is false confidence: assuming alerts and study mode mean a teen is already protected. Common Sense urges families not to rely on built-in protections alone, to talk about risks (including a bot pretending to be a friend), and to support homework in ways that don't hand the thinking to technology.

Age requirements and supervision

  • Under OpenAI's Terms of Use, users must be at least 13 (or the digital-consent age in their country). Under-18s need a parent or guardian's permission.
  • Common Sense goes further and asks OpenAI to treat ChatGPT as 18+ until protections are proven with independent testing.
  • At IAU Kids we treat ChatGPT as a tool that requires adult supervision (tool_min_age 13).

Try this at home

"Alerts vs. conversation": review ChatGPT's parental settings together (if you use them) and run a harmless study-mode check: ask for help on one homework problem and see whether the "show me the answer" shortcut appears. Then agree out loud on (1) who to call in a real crisis (family, school counselor, a local hotline), (2) that no alert replaces talking to a trusted adult, and (3) that homework only counts if they can explain it without looking at the screen.

Sources

  1. ChatGPT for Teens Poses Unacceptable Risk to Kids, Common Sense Media Finds · 2026-10-07
  2. ChatGPT for Teens risk assessment (Youth AI Safety Institute) · 2026-10
  3. OpenAI Terms of Use (minimum age) · accessed 2026-11-05
  4. ChatGPT for Teens safeguards don't work, risk assessment finds (Marketplace) · 2026-11-05

Want your kid to learn AI with guidance and purpose?

Discover the AI course for kids and teens ages 8 to 16.

See the course

Comments

No published comments yet.

Please don't share personal information about minors (full names, school, exact age, photos or location). Comments are reviewed before they're published.